?url_ver=Z39.88-2004&rft_val_fmt=info%3Aofi%2Ffmt%3Akev%3Amtx%3Adc&rft.title=PERTIMBANGAN+HAKIM+DALAM+PENJATUHAN+PIDANA+YANG+BERBEDA+TERHADAP+PELAKU+TINDAK+PIDANA+NARKOTIKA+(Studi+Putusan+Nomor%3A+13%2FPid.Sus%2F2022%2FPN.Tjk+dengan+Putusan+Nomor%3A+5832+K%2FPid.Sus%2F2022)%0D%0A&rft.creator=HAIKAL%2C+SURYAWAN&rft.subject=345+Hukum+pidana&rft.description=Penjatuhan+pidana+oleh+Majelis+Hakim+yang+berbeda+terhadap+perkara+yang+sama+adalah+salah+satu+bentuk+disparitas+Putusan+hakim.+Perbedaan+Putusan+antara+pengadilan+tingkat+pertama+(judex+facti)+dan+pengadilan+tingkat+kasasi+(judex+jurist)+masih+sering+terjadi+di+Indonesia+akibat+adanya+kesalahan%0D%0Apenerapan+hukum+pada+saat+pemeriksaan+fakta+(judex+facti).+Penelitian+ini+berfokus+dan+bertujuan+untuk+%3A+(1)+Pertimbangan+hakim+pada+judex+facti+dan+judex+jurist+pada+Putusan+nomor+%3A+13%2FPid.Sus%2F2022%2FPN.Tjk+dengan+Putusan+Nomor%3A+5832K%2FPid.Sus%2F2022+dan+(2)+Putusan+Nomor+13%2FPid.Sus.2022.PN.%0D%0ATjk+dengan+Putusan+Nomor+5832K%2FPid.Sus%2F2022+telah+mencerminkan+rasa+keadilan+bagi+masyarakat.+Pendekatan+masalah+yang+digunakan+dalam+penelitian+ini+yaitu+dengan+cara%0D%0Apendekatan+yuridis+normatif+dan+pendekatan+yuridis+empiris%2C+yaitu+data+primer+dan+data+sekunder%2C+Narasumber+merupakan+Hakim+pada+Pengadilan+Tinggi+Tanjungkarang%2C+Hakim+pada+Pengadilan+Negeri+Tanjungkarang%2C+Jaksa+pada+Kejaksaan+Negeri+Bandar+Lampung%2C+dan+Dosen+Bagian+Hukum+Pidana+Fakultas+Hukum+Universitas+Lampung%2C+Penelitian+skripsi+ini+menggunakan+analisis+deskriptif+kualitatif.+Berdasarkan+hasil+penelitian+dan+pembahasan%2C+menunjukkan+bahwa+Putusan+nomor+%3A+13%2FPid.Sus%2F2022%2FPN.Tjk+telah+dibatalkan+oleh+Putusan+kasasi+nomor+%3A+5832+K%2FPid.Sus%2F2022+karena+judex+jurist+berpendapat+bahwa+judex+facti+telah+salah+dalam+melakukan+penerapan+hukum%2C+yaitu+pada+saat+pembuktian.+Dalam+proses+pembuktian+di+persidangan%2C+dua+orang+saksi+(Terdakwa+dalam+perkara+lain)+yang+menyebabkan+Terdakwa+tertangkap+telah+mencabut%0D%0Aketerangannya+yang+ada+di+dalam+BAP.+Dalam+Putusan+kasasi+nomor+%3A+5832+K%2FPid.Sus%2F2022+judex+jurist+berpendapat+bahwa+pencabutan+keterangan+di+muka+persidangan+tanpa+alasan+merupakan+petunjuk+terhadap+adanya+suatu+tindak+pidana.+Oleh+karenanya+judex+juris+menghujum+terdakwa+dengan%0D%0Apidana+mati.+Saran+dari+penelitian+ini+adalah%2C+yaitu+untuk+meminimalisir+terjadinya+kesalahan+penerapan+hukum+tidak+boleh+ada+aparat+penegak+hukum+yang+memiliki+kepentingan+pribadi+dalam+melakukan+penegakan+hukum.+perlu+juga%0D%0Aadanya+optimalisasi+pengawasan+dalam+melakukan+penegakan+hukum%2C+dan+menghilangkan+budaya+korupsi.%0D%0A%0D%0AKata+kunci+%3A+Pertimbangan+Hakim%2C+Penjatuhan+Pidana%2C+Narkotika%0D%0A%0D%0A%0D%0A%0D%0A%0D%0AThe+imposition+of+criminal+penalties+by+different+Panels+of+Judges+on+the+same+case+is+one+form+of+disparity+in+Judges'+Decisions.+Differences+in+Decisions+between+the+first+instance+court+(judex+facti)+and+the+cassation+court+(judex+jurist)+still+often+occur+in+Indonesia+due+to+errors+in+the%0D%0Aapplication+of+the+law+during+the+examination+of+facts+(judex+facti).+This+study+focuses+on+and+aims+to%3A+(1)+Considerations+of+judges+on+judex+facti+and+judex+jurist+in+Decision+number%3A+13%2FPid.Sus%2F2022%2FPN.Tjk+with+Decision+Number%3A+5832+K%2FPid.Sus%2F2022+and+(2)+Decision+number%3A+13%2FPid.Sus%2F2022%2FPN.Tjk+with+Decision+Number%3A+5832+K%2FPid.Sus%2F2022+has+reflected+a+sense+of+justice+for%0D%0Athe+community.+The+problem+approach+used+in+this+study+is+by+means+of+a+normative+legal+approach+and+an+empirical+legal+approach%2C+namely+primary+data+and+secondary+data.+The+informants+are+Judges+at+the+Tanjungkarang+High+Court%2C%0D%0AJudges+at+the+Tanjungkarang+District+Court%2C+Prosecutors+at+the+Bandar+Lampung+District+Attorney's+Office%2C+and+Lecturers+in+the+Criminal+Law+Department+of+the+Faculty+of+Law%2C+University+of+Lampung.+This+thesis+research+uses+qualitative+descriptive+analysis.+Based+on+the+results+of+the+research+and+discussion%2C+it+shows+that+Decision+number%3A+13%2FPid.Sus%2F2022%2FPN.Tjk+has+been+overturned+by+the+cassation+decision+number%3A+5832+K%2FPid.Sus%2F2022+because+the+judex+jurist+is+of+the+opinion+that+the+judex+facti+has+made+a+mistake+in+applying+the+law%2C+namely+at+the+time+of+proof.+In+the+process+of+proof+at+the+trial%2C+two+witnesses+(Defendants+in+other+cases)+who+caused+the+Defendant+to+be+arrested+have%0D%0Awithdrawn+their+statements+in+the+BAP.+In+the+cassation+decision+number%3A+5832+K%2FPid.Sus%2F2022%2C+the+judex+jurist+is+of+the+opinion+that+the+withdrawal+of+the+statement+in+the+court+appearance+without+reason+is+an+indication+of+a+criminal+act.+Therefore%2C+judex+juris+sentenced+the+defendant+to+death.+The+suggestion+from+this+research+is%2C+that+is%2C+to+minimize+the+occurrence+of+errors+in+the+application+of+the+law%2C+there+should+be+no+law+enforcement+officers+who+have+personal+interests+in+enforcing+the+law.+There+also+needs+to%0D%0Abe+optimization+of+supervision+in+enforcing+the+law%2C+and+eliminating+the+culture+of+corruption.%0D%0A%0D%0AKeywords%3A+Judge's+Consideration%2C+Criminal+Sentencing%2C+Narcotics&rft.publisher=HUKUM&rft.date=2025-06-17&rft.type=Skripsi&rft.type=NonPeerReviewed&rft.format=text&rft.identifier=http%3A%2F%2Fdigilib.unila.ac.id%2F89830%2F1%2Fabstrak.pdf&rft.format=text&rft.identifier=http%3A%2F%2Fdigilib.unila.ac.id%2F89830%2F2%2Fskripsi%2520full.pdf&rft.format=text&rft.identifier=http%3A%2F%2Fdigilib.unila.ac.id%2F89830%2F3%2Fskripsi%2520full%2520tanpa%2520pembahasan.pdf&rft.identifier=++HAIKAL%2C+SURYAWAN++(2025)+PERTIMBANGAN+HAKIM+DALAM+PENJATUHAN+PIDANA+YANG+BERBEDA+TERHADAP+PELAKU+TINDAK+PIDANA+NARKOTIKA+(Studi+Putusan+Nomor%3A+13%2FPid.Sus%2F2022%2FPN.Tjk+dengan+Putusan+Nomor%3A+5832+K%2FPid.Sus%2F2022).++HUKUM%2C+UNIVERSITAS+LAMPUNG.+++++&rft.relation=http%3A%2F%2Fdigilib.unila.ac.id%2F89830%2F